Exactly how Davis was injured is the question swirling around the league.
Two witnesses to the incident from within the Browns organization said Davis injured his shoulder in a post-practice drill in which he was not wearing pads and the linebacker that plowed into him was. Three other NFL sources corroborated the witnesses' account.
A Browns spokesman said Saturday it is not true.
Once he denied the events, the sources were contacted Saturday for a second time - some for a third or fourth -- and asked about the incident again.
Each repeated the same details. Davis was injured during a pass blocking drill in what the Browns call a post-practice "opportunity period" when a linebacker in pads "got frisky" and "trucked" Davis, who was not in pads.
To read about the response of the NFL and NFLPA about the incident, you must be an ESPN Insider.
The NFL has been aware of this incident and has been looking into it, a league spokesman said this weekend.
News of the accident filtered to Washington last week. A spokesman for the NFL Players Association called it "an outrage." The union has considered filing a grievance about the incident.
However, an NFLPA source said Davis is extremely hesitant to do this out of fear for his job, and that without his support it could be difficult to generate a case.
It also is uncertain what the NFLPA could grieve if the Browns pay Davis his full $310,000 base salary and try not to pay him the $215,000 on his split contract. But even if the issue were to fade away, the NFLPA is going to do what it can to make sure it doesn't.
"This is an outrage," a high-ranking NFLPA source said. "We have a no-pads rule for offseason activities. We've never seen a need to have a rule that if some guy has on pads, he can't take on a guy without pads. The [NFL] commissioner's office needs to look into this."
A sixth-round pick from Clemson, Davis initially injured his shoulder during the Browns season-opening loss to the Minnesota Vikings. But it was not severe enough for him to miss any time until he aggravated it and tore his labrum in the days leading up to Cleveland's game against Cincinnati.
In the days after that, numerous people voiced complaints about the events that transpired. The Browns said it did not occur as people are saying.