The great AL MVP debate

Justin Verlander and Jacoby Ellsbury both put up MVP-caliber seasons in 2011. US Presswire

If you are looking for precedents for the AL Most Valuable Player Award voting, maybe the best could be drawn from the 1876 presidential election, when there was no consensus and the guy who won the popular vote wound up losing. Thankfully, federal troops will not be involved in the resolution of today's MVP decision.

But the arguments will go on long past 2 p.m., when the voting results will be announced. It's possible that Justin Verlander will get the most first-place votes and still lose, because some voters have chosen to keep him off their ballots entirely. Jose Bautista had the best offensive numbers of any AL player, and yet he may lose because the Toronto Blue Jays were never in contention -- a dynamic which reignited the conversation about what actually defines "most valuable." Miguel Cabrera was the most consistent force for the Detroit Tigers. Curtis Granderson had big-time production, with 136 runs and 119 RBIs, but by season's end, there was debate about whether Granderson was the MVP on his own team, over Robinson Cano.

And the Boston Red Sox had a trio of MVP candidates all year, from Dustin Pedroia to Adrian Gonzalez to Jacoby Ellsbury, and they all were in the lineup as Boston suffered the greatest September collapse in baseball history.

The guess here is that Verlander will get the most first-place votes, but because of how splintered the voting figures to be, the key will be holding down one of the top three spots on as many ballots as possible. And it figures that Bautista and Ellsbury will be ranked No. 1, No. 2 or No. 3 on almost all the ballots, and will wind up being the Rutherford B. Hayes of the 2011 AL MVP voting.

I emailed a handful of talent evaluators about what they saw in Ellsbury this year, as he emerged to become one of the best players in the majors. Their responses:

From an AL evaluator: "Jacoby Ellsbury is a freak athlete that put every aspect of his game together this year. He's always been a top-notch fly-chaser in centerfield, and somehow he took it to another level defensively. On the offensive side, he's been a revelation. Previously, he used to control the strike zone and take defensive swings. Now he's attacking and looking to punish the first quality strike he sees. Plus, he's found a way to create extension and loft throughout his swing, which has enabled him to go from a player that previously poked at the baseball and now he's become a multi-faceted player capable of destruction."

From an NL evaluator: "Two factors for me on Ellsbury. 1.) He got healthy and got his strength back. 2.) He changed his approach to more power than getting on-base and running; the increased power coincides with decreased stolen base, lower walk, and higher strikeout totals. He's healthy and continues to mature as a player, but it is a different approach at the plate."

From an AL scout: "Ellsbury seemed to understand exactly what was expected of him this year in terms of the day to day stuff, playing even though he wasn't necessarily feeling like he was 100 percent. He kept an impressively even keel and excelled even in high leverage situations because of it. He seemed like he was comfortable with the expectations of him and did seem to carry some of last year with him this season as motivation. It seemed like the maturation process just kicked into high speed this year, he deserves a ton of credit or taking it to the next level and making The Leap."

From an AL evaluator: "He has gotten stronger, when he first came up it was light contact and a speed game. I don't think he will ever repeat the 2011 season, but with a threat of power, his OBP will go up as pitchers just can't challenge him. He's solid in center field, taking better routes to balls, arm is short but you can't take too much from him. So the main thing is he has gotten stronger and staying through the ball better that makes him a power threat and a more complete player."

From ESPN Stats and Info:

• Verlander is attempting to become the first Tigers pitcher to win the Cy Young since Willie Hernandez in 1984 and the first pitcher to win both the Cy Young and the MVP award in the same season since Dennis Eckersley in 1992 with the Athletics.

• Ellsbury, after recording the first 30-HR/30-SB season in Red Sox history, is attempting to become the first Red Sox MVP winner since Dustin Pedroia in 2008. It would be the first time since Fred Lynn (1975) and Jim Rice (1978) that two Red Sox players won the MVP in a four-year span.

There would be no wrong choice today, writes Richard Griffin. Tony Paul writes of five gems that Verlander threw during the 2011 season.


• The NL MVP will be announced later this week, Tom Haudricourt writes.

• As I wrote the column this morning, sad news about the Seattle Mariners' Greg Halman broke -- he was reportedly stabbed to death.

• The Phillies' trade for Ty Wigginton -- in which the Colorado Rockies will eat half of Wigginton's $4 million salary -- may well end Philadelphia's push for Michael Cuddyer. Wigginton can help fill in at first in the first half of the year when Ryan Howard will be out, and he can play third and second and be an occasional fill-in in the outfield.

The trade allows Jordan Pacheco to ascend into the role that Wigginton held for a lot of last year. The Rockies think that Pacheco, who had a handful of at-bats last year, will hit in the big leagues; he has always hit in the minors.

• Bobby Valentine will interview with the Red Sox today, writes John Tomase. Steve Buckley writes about Valentine here.

Larry Lucchino, who has been Valentine's patron saint in this process, has always been in charge with the Red Sox, writes Silverman.

• A Cincinnati Reds prospect was named to the AFL All-Star team.

• The players seem to be in favor of HGH testing, writes Phil Rogers. There is a wide presumption among scouts and executives that some players are cheating; in fact, there is one player whose physical development draws guffaws from some in the sport because of his Canseco-like growth.

• Mike Matheny lost his home in a legal fight, writes Jake Wagman.

And today will be better than yesterday.