Answer Guys: Just how good is Chase Headley?

You have questions, we have answers. The Answer Guys is an Insider service in which ESPN.com experts personally answer questions about your fantasy team. We present a few of the more challenging questions we've received from Insiders and our answers.

Should I drop David Murphy for Chase Headley?
Wes Padgett

Dave: I know it's difficult to pass on the hype of a young rookie call-up, but I would stick with Murphy for now. The just-promoted Headley is an attractive option and will certainly succeed as the Padres' new everyday left fielder, but the chances of him outperforming David Murphy from here on out is pretty slim.