When a top player retires, the question is inevitable: Is he a Hall of Famer? In the case of Joe Nieuwendyk, who abruptly retired on Wednesday due to chronic back problems, I offer a thumb's up. And, just for the record, I think I have a pretty high standard when it comes to such an honor. For instance, I wouldn't have voted for the induction of Clarke Gillies, Cam Neely or Bernie Federko. After all, it's not the Hockey Hall of Really Good. It's the Hockey Hall of Fame, a club for the elite. I think Nieuwendyk fits in that elite class.