After Chandler Stanton's 45-yard field goal put the Mountaineers on top with 5:45 to play, the defense held but Robert Lefevre's 45-yard punt pinned Appalachian State on its 8-yard line with four minutes remaining.
Noel then carried five-straight times, the last two 41- and 22-yard bursts that put the Mountaineers (3-1) on the Marshall 5. Quarterback Chase Brice then knelt down three times to run out the clock.
After the second of Brice's touchdowns, Rasheen Ali had a 97-yard kickoff return to give Marshall a 20-14 lead. But Brice capped a third long drive with a touchdown two seconds before halftime to put Appalachian State back on top 21-20.
Ali's touchdown run gave Marshall (2-2) a 30-21 lead entering the fourth quarter.
The former conference rivals from the FCS days were meeting for the second time as FBS schools with Marshall winning 17-7 last season.
Georgia Bulldogs football commit Marcus Washington Jr. reclassifies to skip senior year, join 2022 class
Marcus Washington Jr., the No. 10 cornerback in the 2023 ESPN 300, announced he was reclassifying and joining Georgia's incoming freshman class.
College football independents preview: Notre Dame, BYU, Army burning questions and top players
The Irish have a new coach but need to settle on a quarterback, and the Cougars seem to be loaded. We break down those teams and the other indies.
Tennessee Volunteers, Virginia Cavaliers to open 2023 college football season in Nashville
Tennessee and Virginia will face off to open the 2023 season at Nissan Stadium in Nashville, the schools announced Monday.
College football spring transfer tracker: Top players in the portal, big moves and analysis
Who are the best college football players who have entered -- and exited -- the transfer portal during the second wave?
College football's top 25 future defense power rankings
We take a look at which programs will have the best defenses over the next three seasons. Plenty of teams are in contention for the top spot, but which team has the brightest future?
Alabama's Saban calls for more parity in football
The Crimson Tide's Nick Saban tells The Paul Finebaum Show that he'd like to see a return to the days of a more level playing field in college football.